EP 11 | IS THE STOCK MARKET A PONZI SCHEME?

Play episode
Hosted by
ANDREW LANOIE

Welcome back to another episode. Name a financial arrangement or system where current investors’ profits are dependent on cash from new investors. If you said Ponzi scheme, you would be correct. But if you said publicly traded stocks, you would also be correct. But before I explain why stocks are a Ponzi, let me first make a distinction. I’m not saying all stocks are Ponzi’s, just the ones that perpetually don’t pay dividends. Why is that?

Well, there’s two ways. Investors can make money in stocks. One is from dividends and the other is to capital gains by selling the stock in the future for more than the purchase price. If a company doesn’t pay dividends, the only way their investors can profit is from new investors willing to pay a higher price, which sounds like a Ponzi scheme. Companies that don’t pay dividends haven’t established a history of consistent profitability, and frankly, don’t have the confidence to make the dividend payments. Their stock prices rise and fall at the whim of investors. Dividend paying stocks on the other hand are not Ponzi’s because the companies paying them are legitimate businesses with a history of profitability.

Their stock has an intrinsic value independent of the market price of the stock. In other words, the investor will still receive their dividends as long as they hold the stock no matter what the price is on the stock market. Dividends stocks are rooted in profitable enterprises, capable of paying those dividends. Delta airlines, Intel, Walmart, Apple, Coca-Cola are great examples of companies that pay dividends. They are all long running businesses and have a history of profitability. Dividend paying companies pay their investors from profits. Dividendless companies do not pay investors at all. Investors must rely on the greater fool theory to make money with these stocks, making them speculators. Buying, and trading in the hopes of picking up a bargain from one fool and turning it around and selling it for a profit down the road to a greater fool. This is what makes for a volatile stock market.

Here’s why, because a substantial amount of market capitalization of the stock market is not rooted in sound financial principles, but on speculation and the wealth in the stock market is Phantom wealth. Investors are continually chasing the next Facebook or Amazon frequently buying and dumping stocks in pursuit of the next best thing. And usually a company that has never been profitable, I’m looking at you Snapchat. Here’s a prime example of Phantom wealth. Uber’s market cap currently sits around $57 billion, but it has yet to turn a profit and has no prospect of turning one anytime soon. The market cap is based on hopes and dreams and in a market downturn, those hopes, and dreams will be dashed. This is the reason the market cap of the stock market vaporized during the last financial crisis. And we’ll

do it again during the next financial crisis. It’s because cash is king during a crisis and investors in non-dividend paying stocks will be happy to unload the mystical rainbows and unicorns for cold, hard cash. Even if it’s a lot less than they initially paid for that stock. That’s why the Ponzi nature of stocks makes the market dangerous and volatile.

The problem with the stock market is that dividendless paying stocks are the ones that get all the attention. Dividend paying companies are usually older, involved in unsexy businesses. The whole buy-low sell-high gamble is the only game that’s being talked about on Fox business, CNBC and financial news networks, and is also the focus of a lot of financial analysis and research. The rise and fall of stocks are all these financial news sources talk about because they think that’s all investors want to hear. It’s a fact that dividend paying stocks are hit less hard than other stocks during downturns because of the intrinsic value of the dividend stream. However, dividend stocks are not entirely immune to the stress. Even during the most significant crisis, like the last one, some dividend paying companies scaled back their dividends or suspended them altogether.

My point is the stock market is volatile and much of its “wealth” is Phantom and can come and go in an instant. Nothing’s safe in the stock market in a downturn. So why invest in something rooted in a shaky foundation, investors like dividends for the fixed type income they provide. So why not consider another type of investment offering consistent periodic income distributions rooted in an established industry that is not tied to stock market volatility. It’s not sexy or new or the next best thing, but why not consider an alternative investment like real estate? Ultra-high net worth investors are always prepared for recessions. That’s because the vast majority of their investible assets are not tied to the stock market. They prefer alternative assets like real estate that offer consistent income distributions and are asset back and resistant to market downturns. Ultra-high net worth investors have long allocated, more than 10% of their investible assets in commercial real estate for those reasons alone, such as affordable housing are not only resistant to downturns, but actually thrive in them. With the passage of the jobs act secure alternative investments are no longer exclusive to the wealthy. They are readily accessible to more qualified investors than ever before. And there’s no excuse for serious investors not to break the vicious cycle of the wall street Ponzi scheme and invest in something tangible in volatility free like commercial real estate.

Join the discussion

11 comments
  • I enjoy you because of all of your effort on this blog. Debby delights in conducting internet research and it’s easy to see why. A number of us hear all about the compelling manner you create effective guides by means of the blog and boost contribution from other ones about this area of interest and my child has been becoming educated a great deal. Enjoy the remaining portion of the new year. You’re carrying out a fabulous job.

  • A lot of thanks for all your efforts on this site. Gloria enjoys engaging in investigation and it’s easy to understand why. Almost all know all concerning the dynamic means you deliver great items on the web blog and as well encourage contribution from other people on that concern plus our daughter is actually being taught a lot. Have fun with the remaining portion of the new year. You’re the one conducting a glorious job.

  • A lot of thanks for all your valuable efforts on this site. Kate loves engaging in investigation and it’s really easy to understand why. I know all concerning the dynamic medium you give important secrets on this web blog and as well as foster participation from others on that content plus our daughter is always discovering a lot. Have fun with the remaining portion of the new year. You are conducting a great job.

  • I am only writing to make you understand what a remarkable experience our princess undergone viewing your webblog. She picked up some things, which included what it is like to possess an ideal teaching spirit to make the mediocre ones without difficulty master specified tortuous things. You undoubtedly surpassed readers’ expected results. Thanks for rendering those useful, trustworthy, revealing as well as unique tips on your topic to Mary.

  • A lot of thanks for all your efforts on this site. Gloria loves engaging in investigation and it’s easy to understand why. Almost all know all concerning the dynamic means you deliver helpful items on the web blog and as well encourage contribution from other people on that concern plus our daughter is actually discovering a lot. Have fun with the remaining portion of the new year. You’re the one conducting a good job.

  • I am glad for writing to make you know what a incredible encounter my friend’s girl gained studying your web page. She learned plenty of pieces, which include what it’s like to possess an awesome helping mood to let other folks smoothly know just exactly several multifaceted subject matter. You truly exceeded our own expectations. Thank you for offering these necessary, safe, explanatory and even fun tips about this topic to Julie.

  • I enjoy you because of all of your effort on this blog. Ellie enjoys conducting internet research and it’s easy to see why. All of us hear all about the compelling manner you create efficient ideas by means of the blog and as well cause contribution from other ones about this article and my child is being taught a great deal. Enjoy the remaining portion of the new year. You’re the one carrying out a fantastic job.

  • I precisely had to appreciate you all over again. I’m not certain the things I might have done in the absence of the actual ideas documented by you directly on such field. It became a real distressing condition for me personally, but encountering a new professional form you managed it forced me to jump for delight. I’m just happier for the guidance and even have high hopes you find out what a powerful job you’re doing instructing most people through your blog. I am sure you’ve never encountered all of us.

  • I’m also commenting to let you be aware of of the excellent discovery my cousin’s child enjoyed checking your blog. She discovered a wide variety of details, most notably how it is like to have a marvelous coaching heart to get many more effortlessly fully understand certain complicated matters. You actually did more than my desires. I appreciate you for displaying such great, healthy, educational and also cool guidance on that topic to Evelyn.

More from this show

Let’s get social

Follow Andrew to learn more about his investments and to share the podcasts with friends!

Episode 11